The Energy Mix

Top Menu

  • Special Reports
    • Alberta’s Bitumen Pipe Dream
    • Canada’s Climate Change Election 2019
    • Carbon Farming
    • City and Sub-National Climate Action
    • Drawdown
    • Drive to 1.5
    • The Energy Mix Yearbook 2018
      • Climate Extremes
      • Fossils Go For Broke
      • Renewables (R)Evolution
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Canada’s Contradiction
      • Pipeline Politics
      • COP24
      • Jobs and Just Transition
      • Cities and Sub-Nationals
      • Finance and Divestment
      • Climate Litigation
  • Podcasts & Webinars
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
  • About Us
  • Which Energy Mix is this?
  • Partners
  • Contact

Main Menu

  • Climate & Society
    • Carbon-Free Transition
    • Carbon Levels & Measurement
    • Climate Action/”Blockadia”
    • Climate Denial
    • Climate Policy/Meetings/Negotiations
    • Culture, Curiosities, & Humour
    • Demographics
    • Energy Politics
    • Energy/Carbon Pricing & Economics
    • Energy Subsidies
    • Finance & Investment
    • First Peoples
    • Insurance & Liability
    • International Agencies & Studies
    • Jobs
    • Legal & Regulatory
    • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Methane
    • Travel, Leisure & Recreation
  • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
    • Biodiversity & Habitat
    • Drought, Famine & Wildfires
    • Food Security
    • Forests & Deforestation
    • Health & Safety
    • Heat & Temperature
    • Human Rights & Equity
    • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
    • International Security, Migration & War
    • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Soil & Natural Sequestration
    • Water
  • Demand & Distribution
    • Air & Marine
    • Auto & Alternative Vehicles
    • Batteries/Storage
    • Buildings
    • Cities
    • Electricity Grid
    • Energy Access & Equity
    • Off-Grid
    • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Supply Chains & Consumption
    • Transit
    • Walking & Biking
  • Jurisdictions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Brazil
    • Canada
    • China
    • Europe
    • India
    • International
    • Mexico, Caribbean & Latin America
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Sub-National Governments
    • United States
  • Non-Renewable Energy
    • CCS & Geoengineering
    • Coal
    • Nuclear
    • Oil & Gas
    • Pipelines/Rail Transport
    • Shale & Fracking
    • Tar Sands/Oil Sands
  • Renewable Energy
    • Bioenergy
    • Demand & Efficiency
    • General Renewables
    • Geothermal
    • Hydro
    • Research & Development
    • Solar
    • Wave & Tidal
    • Wind

logo

The Energy Mix

  • Climate & Society
    • Carbon-Free Transition
    • Carbon Levels & Measurement
    • Climate Action/”Blockadia”
    • Climate Denial
    • Climate Policy/Meetings/Negotiations
    • Culture, Curiosities, & Humour
    • Demographics
    • Energy Politics
    • Energy/Carbon Pricing & Economics
    • Energy Subsidies
    • Finance & Investment
    • First Peoples
    • Insurance & Liability
    • International Agencies & Studies
    • Jobs
    • Legal & Regulatory
    • Media, Messaging, & Public Opinion
    • Methane
    • Travel, Leisure & Recreation
  • Climate Impacts & Adaptation
    • Biodiversity & Habitat
    • Drought, Famine & Wildfires
    • Food Security
    • Forests & Deforestation
    • Health & Safety
    • Heat & Temperature
    • Human Rights & Equity
    • Ice Loss & Sea Level Rise
    • International Security, Migration & War
    • Severe Storms & Flooding
    • Soil & Natural Sequestration
    • Water
  • Demand & Distribution
    • Air & Marine
    • Auto & Alternative Vehicles
    • Batteries/Storage
    • Buildings
    • Cities
    • Electricity Grid
    • Energy Access & Equity
    • Off-Grid
    • Petrochemicals & Plastics
    • Supply Chains & Consumption
    • Transit
    • Walking & Biking
  • Jurisdictions
    • Africa
    • Arctic & Antarctica
    • Asia
    • Australia
    • Brazil
    • Canada
    • China
    • Europe
    • India
    • International
    • Mexico, Caribbean & Latin America
    • Middle East
    • Oceans
    • Small Island States
    • South & Central America
    • Sub-National Governments
    • United States
  • Non-Renewable Energy
    • CCS & Geoengineering
    • Coal
    • Nuclear
    • Oil & Gas
    • Pipelines/Rail Transport
    • Shale & Fracking
    • Tar Sands/Oil Sands
  • Renewable Energy
    • Bioenergy
    • Demand & Efficiency
    • General Renewables
    • Geothermal
    • Hydro
    • Research & Development
    • Solar
    • Wave & Tidal
    • Wind
Advanced Search
  • Special Reports
    • Alberta’s Bitumen Pipe Dream
    • Canada’s Climate Change Election 2019
    • Carbon Farming
    • City and Sub-National Climate Action
    • Drawdown
    • Drive to 1.5
    • The Energy Mix Yearbook 2018
      • Climate Extremes
      • Fossils Go For Broke
      • Renewables (R)Evolution
      • Electric Vehicles
      • Canada’s Contradiction
      • Pipeline Politics
      • COP24
      • Jobs and Just Transition
      • Cities and Sub-Nationals
      • Finance and Divestment
      • Climate Litigation
  • Podcasts & Webinars
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Subscribe
  • Donate
  • About Us
  • Which Energy Mix is this?
  • Partners
  • Contact
CanadaEnergy PoliticsFirst PeoplesInternational Agencies & StudiesLegal & RegulatoryTar Sands/Oil SandsWater
Home›Jurisdictions›Canada›Ottawa Just Not Ready to Declare Whether Tar Sands/Oil Sands Tailing Ponds Are Leaking

Ottawa Just Not Ready to Declare Whether Tar Sands/Oil Sands Tailing Ponds Are Leaking

November 21, 2017
November 21, 2017
 
85
1
Share:
  •  
  • 15
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
    15
    Shares
  Print This Story
Wikimedia Commons

Ignoring a decade of research, Canada’s federal government is insisting it can’t tell whether hydrocarbons present in the water of the Athabasca River are leaking out of the seven unlined ponds along its banks, where open pit tar sands/oil sands mines store 1.3 trillion litres of toxic waste tailings from their operations.

The National Observer reports the government made its claim in a response to a complaint filed with NAFTA’s Commission for Environmental Cooperation last June by two environmental groups and a Dene man. At the time, Toronto-based Environmental Defence and the Natural Resources Defense Council alleged Canada was failing to enforce Fisheries Act prohibitions on the release of “deleterious substances” into water frequented by commercial fish species.

Like this story? Subscribe to The Energy Mix and never miss an edition of our free e-digest.

SUBSCRIBE

Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) responded that its enforcement officers and scientists “did not have reasonable grounds to believe that there were violations of the Act” because, “when deleterious substances were found in groundwater samples, enforcement officers could not determine if they came from natural or anthropogenic (i.e. oil sands industrial activity) sources.”

The department said that after five years of failing to establish an industry fingerprint in the “deleterious substances” it detected in groundwater, it gave up and “redirected its enforcement efforts toward other issues.”

The claim that there is no way to tell where contaminants come from appears to be contradicted by the government’s own internal communications, as well as available external science.

The Observer reports that a 2012 internal memo to Harper-era natural resources minister Joe Oliver “shows that federal scientists had discovered a clear presence of tailings toxins in local water sources.”

The memo advised Oliver that “studies have, for the first time, detected potentially harmful, mining-related organic acid contaminants in the groundwater outside a long-established out-of-pit tailings pond.”

Indeed, a study by non-government researchers nearly a decade ago “pegged tailings leakage at 11 million litres a day, potentially reaching 72 million litres per day,” the outlet recalls. Highly regarded limnologist David Schindler reported in a journal article in 2010 that “tailings pond leakage or discharge” was the most likely source of toxic pollutants in the Athabasca. In 2014, federal scientists wrote in the journal Environmental Science and Technology that they had identified an industrial “chemical fingerprint” in Athabasca water contaminants.

“They found not only are those tailings ponds leaking, but it looks like it is flowing pretty much from those tailings ponds, through the ground and into the Athabasca River,” environmental scientist Bill Donahue said at the time.

But other studies have produced more equivocal results. And even with a general conclusion about the source of contaminants in the region’s water, the government may still lack sufficient precision in chemical attribution to take a particular company to court.

Ottawa says it’s working on that. “In an effort to address the knowledge gaps related to identifying seepage from tailings ponds,” it advised the CEC in its submission, “ECCC scientists have been working diligently to develop the scientific tools necessary to determine whether tailings pond seepage is occurring, and its extent and impact.”

But if that’s the case, observes Melody Lepine, a member of Mikisew Cree First Nation whose territory includes much of the tar sands/oil sands operating area, “it’s troubling to know after 50 years there’s still not enough data and research and management of tailings ponds.”

The CEC has 120 working days to review Canada’s submission, then another 60 to schedule an opportunity for the environment ministers of Canada, the U.S., and Mexico to vote on whether the agency should produce a non-binding “factual record” of the case—the stiffest rebuke available to it.

Share:
  •  
  • 15
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
  •  
    15
    Shares
  Print This Story

Find more stories about
CanadaEnergy PoliticsFirst PeoplesInternational Agencies & StudiesLegal & RegulatoryTar Sands/Oil SandsWater

    1 comment

    1. Geoff Smith 22 November, 2017 at 13:04 Reply

      Shocking but so true. Luckily I am 54 years old and I will not have to live through the damage created by the oil and gas industry. Unfortunately, my two teenaged sons will suffer the consequences of decisions made by the so-called president et les freres Koch. Such a great story about greed and ignorance. Where is our modern-day Charles Dickens?

    Leave a reply Cancel reply

    Subscribe to The Energy Mix

    The Energy Mix is your guide to climate change and energy issues and solutions. Whether you’re looking for the latest content on the impacts of climate change, the fossil industries that produce the emissions, renewable energy and energy efficiency alternatives, or climate solutions outside energy, you’ve come to the right place. Please send us your comments and story ideas!

    SEE OUR LATEST DIGEST

    Recent Posts

    Carbon Levels & MeasurementCarbon-Free TransitionChinaClimate Action/"Blockadia"Climate Policy/Meetings/NegotiationsEnergy PoliticsEnergy/Carbon Pricing & EconomicsFinance & InvestmentFirst PeoplesHuman Rights & MigrationIndiaInternational Agencies & StudiesMedia, Messaging, & Public OpinionMiddle EastSmall Island StatesUnited States

    U.S. Declared ‘Climate Criminal’ as ‘Stalemated’ COP 25 Limps to a Close

    Reporters on the ground described two weeks of stalemated United Nations climate negotiations limping to a close, a diplomat branded the United States a “climate criminal” for its stance on ...
    • http://www.greenpeace.org/canada/en/campaigns/Energy/tarsands/

      Decision on Teck Frontier Mega-Mine Will Test Canada’s Climate Action Commitment

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • Alberta Launches ‘Hopeful, Uplifting’ War Room After Kenney’s Ottawa Visit Fizzles

      December 13, 2019
       
      Primary Author Compiled by The Energy Mix staff
      December 13, 2019
    • Swiss Parliament May Instruct Central Bank to Divest Fossil Assets

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • Ottawa Won’t Confirm Trans Mountain Timeline or Budget as Cost Estimate Balloons to $12 Billion [Petition]

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • Chevron to Dump 50% Share in Kitimat LNG, Writes Off $10 Billion in Oil and Gas Assets

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • Minority Communities Face Greatest Risk as Atlantic Coast Pipeline Pushes Into Rural America

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • U.S. Heat Waves Cause 25,000 More Premature Births Per Year

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • Harbour Air Completes First Test Flight for Battery-Powered Seaplane

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • Long History of Waste, Shrinkage Due to Climate Change Put Majestic Colorado River At Risk

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • District Energy Systems Gain Ground Despite High Up-Front Cost, Low Gas Prices

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • Thunberg Named Time Magazine Person of the Year

      December 13, 2019
       
      December 13, 2019
    • Jonathan Wilkinson COP 25 climate Canada

      Canada Pledges Net Zero by 2050 as Major Emitters Dig In to Block COP 25 Progress

      December 11, 2019
       
      Primary Author Compiled by Mitchell Beer @mitchellbeer
      December 11, 2019
    • VW

      Enviros Call for Billions in Fines After VW Canada Pleads Guilty to Dieselgate Charges

      December 11, 2019
       
      December 11, 2019
    • Wilkinson Throws Cold Water on Carbon Credits for LNG Exports

      December 11, 2019
       
      December 11, 2019

    Partners

    • About the Energy Mix
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    Copyright 2019 © Smarter Shift Inc. and Energy Mix Productions Inc. All rights reserved.